Všetky hlásenia
Hlásenia hry 7 Divů světa
#12057: "Problem in ELO calculation"
O čom je toto hlásenie?
Čo sa stalo? Prosím vyber z nasledujúcich
Návrh: podľa môjho názoru by nasledovné mohlo výrazne zlepšiť implementáciu hry
Podrobný popis
• Prosím presne a stručne vysvetli svoj podnet, aby bolo čo najjednoduchšie pochopiť, ako to myslíš.
I noticed that the ELO calculation was mistaken for this game. I was the lowest ranking player, won, yet earned less points than the third player. (Precision, all players with K factor 20). The third player actually got the sum of all points listed while other players get it divided by around 3.
-> Need to check this, there must be a bug in the calculation.• Aký prehliadač používaš?
Safari v12
História hlásenia
10 mar 2019 10:37 • Kaerdwin • Problém zatiaľ nebol zopakovaný programátormi:
See final scores and ELO variations for table #49548852
14 sep 2019 13:29 • mick007 • Tento návrh ešte nebol analyzovaný vývojármi:
same constatation in the game : table=57373502
1st win less ELO points than the 3rd, and they have quite the same ELO (100 vs 102)
1st win less ELO points than the 3rd, and they have quite the same ELO (100 vs 102)
19 mar 2020 13:04 • jimmyjames008 • Tento návrh ešte nebol analyzovaný vývojármi:
I also cannot figure out how they are determining the final ELO a person will gain or loose. They show you did against each opponent, then give you a random value.
It's not the sum of the ELO gained or lost against each player, or a multiple of that either.
It's not the sum of the ELO gained or lost against each player, or a multiple of that either.
9 apr 2020 6:41 • liverhof • Tento návrh ešte nebol analyzovaný vývojármi:
Hallo,
I didn’t receive correct points for my Victory.
It s not the first time!
I didn’t receive correct points for my Victory.
It s not the first time!
18 apr 2020 14:37 • labouh • Tento návrh ešte nebol analyzovaný vývojármi:
see also game 7 Wonders #49548852
2nd player earned more than first with same K factor and ELO...
2nd player earned more than first with same K factor and ELO...
21 apr 2020 21:36 • John Crabsto • Tento návrh ešte nebol analyzovaný vývojármi:
Please check also game #77578216. No correct points at all, I think for any of the players. Thanks!
10 máj 2020 22:05 • astridrenate • Tento návrh ešte nebol analyzovaný vývojármi:
Here is a screenshot:
i.imgur.com/FtwsBkO.png
shows incorrect ELO sum for player astridrenate,
the other players got the correct sum.
i.imgur.com/FtwsBkO.png
shows incorrect ELO sum for player astridrenate,
the other players got the correct sum.
29 máj 2020 17:27 • Alvaro28 • Tento návrh ešte nebol analyzovaný vývojármi:
La somme des points ELO est fausse sur de nombreuses tables. Entre le bon total et le total (faux) pris en compte par BGA, il existe un rapport qui varie, suivant les tables: voir liste ci-dessous.
Pire, pour la table 90262900, le ratio 2/3 existe, mais pas pour tous les joueurs !!!
voir les tables suivantes; entre parenthèse le ratio:
87777139 (1/2)
87782304 (1/2)
88910020 (2/3)
89745652 (2/3)
89745675 (2/5)
89745680 (2/3)
89745822 (2/3)
89747707 (2/3)
Merci de votre retour
Pire, pour la table 90262900, le ratio 2/3 existe, mais pas pour tous les joueurs !!!
voir les tables suivantes; entre parenthèse le ratio:
87777139 (1/2)
87782304 (1/2)
88910020 (2/3)
89745652 (2/3)
89745675 (2/5)
89745680 (2/3)
89745822 (2/3)
89747707 (2/3)
Merci de votre retour
12 jún 2020 12:47 • Levosh • Tento návrh ešte nebol analyzovaný vývojármi:
Same issue as above. Incorrect ELO calculation. I was first with the lowest Rank and got +24 ELO, the player placed second got +29 ELO for some reason. Same K factor 20 for both of us. Check table=94893135
14 júl 2020 5:34 • Gerbat • Tento návrh ešte nebol analyzovaný vývojármi:
Jeu: 7 wonders. Table : 101271517
J´ai gagné le match. L´écran a figuré ma victoire et + 11 points ELO. J´avais 418 points. Le système m´a réduit a 391 points !!!!
Cur, quia quomodo ??????
J´ai gagné le match. L´écran a figuré ma victoire et + 11 points ELO. J´avais 418 points. Le système m´a réduit a 391 points !!!!
Cur, quia quomodo ??????
23 nov 2020 20:28 • Julenisse • Tento návrh ešte nebol analyzovaný vývojármi:
Same problem also in table 126374987 and other games I played before. Elo scores of the wins vs each single player don't add up to the total Elo change :(
7 dec 2020 7:08 • Romain672 • Tento návrh ešte nebol analyzovaný vývojármi:
I just checked Gerbat's game.
Apparently, one game before he lost 28 elo because he abandonned a game.
.
.
For Levosh's one, yeah that's really strange.
Apparently, one game before he lost 28 elo because he abandonned a game.
.
.
For Levosh's one, yeah that's really strange.
19 dec 2020 21:58 • Julenisse • Tento návrh ešte nebol analyzovaný vývojármi:
To be honest, the ELO points vs individual players don't sum up to what you get in total in ANY Seven Wonders game that I play. Please check this!
4 feb 2022 18:51 • oezi • Tento návrh ešte nebol analyzovaný vývojármi:
I can confirm that in the original table which was reported (boardgamearena.com/table?table=49548852) that for the third player the multi-player offset wasn't correctly applied.
Playing a 7 player game of "7 Wonders" should lead to a correction factor of 1/3 of the sum of the pairwise ELO calculation.
The expected ELO change should have been:
p1 23.55
p2 11.89
p3 8.29
p4 -0.79
p5 -3.42
p6 -19.74
p7 -19.77
Playing a 7 player game of "7 Wonders" should lead to a correction factor of 1/3 of the sum of the pairwise ELO calculation.
The expected ELO change should have been:
p1 23.55
p2 11.89
p3 8.29
p4 -0.79
p5 -3.42
p6 -19.74
p7 -19.77
18 feb 2024 10:38 • KongKing123 • Tento návrh ešte nebol analyzovaný vývojármi:
Bump to avoid automatic closure.
28 aug 2024 16:42 • KongKing123 • Tento návrh ešte nebol analyzovaný vývojármi:
Bump to avoid automatic closure.
Pridať niečo k tomuto hláseniu
Prosím sem pridaj čokoľvek, čo sa zdá byť podstatné za účelom zreprodukovania tejto závady alebo pochopenia Tvojho podnetu:
- Iné ID stola / ID ťahu
- Vyriešil sa problém pomocou F5?
- Objavil sa problém viackrát? Zakaždým? Náhodne?
- Ak máš screenshot (dobrý zvyk), môžeš použiť Imgur.com na jeho nahranie a skopírovať sem odkaz na neho.
